Sheffield is a residential community in Winterville, NC (Pitt County). 2 closed sales in the last 6 months. Mix: single-family homes (100%).
Current Market — Last 6 Months
$276,750Median sold price (6mo)
$186Median $ / sq ft
2Homes sold (6 mo)
7Median days on market
5All-time closed sales
Source: Pitt County MLS, closed sales through April 2026. Updated monthly.
Homes for Sale in Sheffield
Live Listings from the Pitt County MLS
Filtered to Sheffield, Winterville, NC — updated in real time.
What to Expect in Sheffield
Commute Times from Sheffield
Nearby in Winterville
- Grocery: Food Lion, Aldi, Sam’s Club, Lidl
- Shopping: Kohl’s, Talbots, Walmart Neighborhood Market
- Parks & greenways: Local recreation parks, South Tar River Greenway access
Frequently Asked Questions
▸ What is the median home price in Sheffield?
The median sold price in Sheffield over the last 6 months is $276,750. Median price per heated square foot is $186.
▸ What kinds of homes are in Sheffield?
Sheffield is made up of single-family homes (100%). Total closed sales on record: 5.
▸ When were homes in Sheffield built?
Homes in Sheffield were built between 1998 and 2004.
▸ Does Sheffield have an HOA?
Yes — Sheffield is HOA-managed.
▸ How far is Sheffield from ECU Health?
Approximately 10 minutes by car from ECU Health Medical Center in Greenville, NC.
▸ How many homes have sold in Sheffield?
5 homes have closed in Sheffield across the last 5 years of MLS data, including 2 in the most recent 6 months.
Ready to tour Sheffield?
Al Pinder is a Pitt County specialist with over a decade in this market. Free, no-pressure showings and builder comparisons.
Al Pinder is a Pitt County specialist with over a decade in this market. Free, no-pressure showings and builder comparisons.
Thinking of selling in Sheffield?
We have active buyers on saved searches for this area. Find out what your home is worth in today’s market.
We have active buyers on saved searches for this area. Find out what your home is worth in today’s market.